News RSS Feed Send your news, pictures & videos


Middlewich incinerator bypass pledge: a 'bribe' or a blessing?


A FORECASTED 3,500 jobs could be created in Middlewich if the eastern bypass is completed, according to research by incinerator firm Covanta.

Bosses from the company that wants to build an ‘energy-from waste’ plant in Midpoint 18 business park say the bypass would prompt a ‘substantial investment’ in the town.

“Similar results have been achieved next to other Covanta energy-from-waste facilities,” said Covanta’s managing director Malcolm Chilton.

“In the US for example, schools and high quality housing have been developed alongside Covanta facilities.”

But campaigners from Cheshire Anti-incinerator Network (CHAIN) have accused Covanta of being ‘deceptive’.

Liam Byrne, of CHAIN, added: “We all want more employment in Middlewich, of course, but common sense dictates that huge toxin emitting rubbish burning incinerators drive existing employers away and deter new ones moving in.”

As reported in the Guardian, Covanta has promised £2.5million to link Pochin Way with Booth Lane and Midpoint 18 if its plans in Middlewich go ahead.

The completion of the eastern bypass has been an aspiration for Middlewich for about 15 years and is already two-thirds built.

Covanta’s gesture has been met with a mixed response from the community with some welcoming the news and others describing it as a ‘bribe’.

Mr Byrne said: “The ‘bribe’ offered by Covanta to pay for what amounts to about 20 per cent of the cost of a bypass is nothing more than a cynical ploy to tempt Cheshire East Council to ignore its responsibilities and the expressed wishes of the people of Middlewich.

“Their case for building it which they have put forward until now has been totally discredited and they are scrabbling around for a last resort.

“In their arrogance, Covanta clearly hopes that the core reasons for opposing their insane plan will be forgotten in the rush to grasp their 'thirty pieces of silver'.”

Brian Reay, property director at Pochins, reckons the completion of the bypass will unlock the potential of 43 hectares of development land at Midpoint 18, which already has planning permission.

He added: “The provision of the bypass is of huge strategic importance and, given the current economic climate, without this commitment from Pochins and Covanta and the public sector, the bypass may otherwise not see the light of day for many more years to come.

“Well over 2,000 jobs have been brought to Middlewich through the success of the existing phases of Midpoint 18.

“Providing the bypass and enabling Midpoint 18 to be completed will position Middlewich in the best possible light to attract further investment and job creation in the short, medium and long term.”

But Mr Byrne said: “Yet again they have underestimated the intelligence and sense of communal responsibility of the people of Middlewich and, indeed, of Cheshire.

“They conveniently forget that more than 60 per cent of the local adult population have signed the CHAIN petition opposing their scheme on the grounds of risks to public health, damage to the environment and the sheer stupidity of its location.

“They also ignore the important fact that more than 2500 formal planning objections have already been lodged.”

Comments(7)

man on the cheshire omnibus says...
12:04pm Tue 22 Dec 09

Come on CHAIN You can do better than these lies You are pedaling. The environment agency would not allow it to be built if there was ANY Risk to public health or damage to the environment and You know this. Stop telling these tales. Seems like CHAIN Are the only ones bribing the public here!

uMickey says...
6:07pm Tue 22 Dec 09

Covanta have done no more than we expected them to. We are very aware that such alleged 'community bribery tactics' are commonplace. They are merely designed to sway local residents to say yes. However, I suspect the people of Middlewich will not be swayed by such a pathetic insult to our community and people.

Liam Byrne says...
6:08pm Tue 22 Dec 09

If your anonymous contributor who calls himself 'man on cheshire omnibus' can prove that I have told lies in any of statements I have made on behalf of CHAIN as quoted in your article, then he should do so. Otherwise he should shut up and your readers can safely assume that he is incapable of arguing against the case we have put forward and, in his apparent desperation to support Covanta, he has had to use smear tactics.

The weird logic of his accusation that CHAIN are 'bribing the public' escapes me. What bribe for what purpose?

Sadly, I guess we can expect more of this twaddle from the pyromaniac
supporters as we get closer to the time when the Cheshire East Council
must decide whether to support Covanta or the thousands of Middlewich people who have made up their minds that they do not want their health and their town ruined
by a giant trash incinerator.

uMickey says...
6:11pm Tue 22 Dec 09

Man on the Cheshire Omnibus clearly does not live in Middlewich or represent the views of its residents.

Sir, we can only hope that you bought a one-way ticket to a place many many miles from Middlewich.

uMickey says...
6:14pm Tue 22 Dec 09

BEWARE! - it is not at all unususal for employyes or agents of the developer to mascarade as residents who support the proposed development(s)

Liam Byrne says...
1:44pm Thu 24 Dec 09

Perhaps, Mr Reay, Property Director at Pochins, could inform us if his company has any plans to compensate home owners for the approximate £50 million total reduction in residential property values in the area if his dream of a waste incinerator in Middlewich ever came true.

Any bets on what his answer will be?

Steve Tea says...
9:53am Sat 26 Dec 09

A FORECASTED 3,500 jobs could be created in Middlewich.

Forcasted means to calculate or estimate in advance.

Year 1 = 3500 jobs. If you believe Conventa.
Year 2 = 50 jobs. The bypass has been built. The incinerator has been built and operationalise the service
Year 3 = 25 jobs. Service operationalised.

Convanta should tell the people the truth on the number of jobs guarenteed in the long term.

How many full time jobs will their be in year 5?

What is benefit of these jobs to the local community?

What is the downside of the incinerator?
1) Ash. Fly Ash and Bottom Ash. Fly ash can contain copper, zinc, cadmium, lead and other dangerous by products of the burning process including dioxins and furans. Does Convanta intend to monitor all aspects of waste leaving the chimney and report on it?
2) Increased CO2 levels from incineration
3) Increased C02 levels for lorries transporting to waste.
4) Odour - From the incineration process and from the extra vehicles servicing the incinerator.
5) Accident - 300 vehicles extra a day. What is the accident impact assesment for this volume. How many children will lose their lives underneath the wheels a lorry.
6) Health - What is the impact to people's health?
a) From the incinerator
b) Incineration process
c) The 300 lorries

Convanta will not winning over the local population unless the start to be honest on the true impact positive and negative to incineration in Middlewich.

Health before American Profits.


Most popular


Want to share your opinion, leave a tribute or comment on a news story? It's easy!

You can register for free here and comment on any of our stories.

Your news, Your views.

Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »

Local Businesses